Press Note, April 25, 2011
Apex Court Dismisses ISKCON Mumbai’s Plea
Honorable Justices of Supreme court, Justice J M Panchal and Justice H L Gokhale dismissed two special leave petitions filed by ISKCON Mumbai to initiate contempt action against Sri Chanchalapathi Dasa, Sri Stoka Krishna Dasa and seven other members of the Governing council of ISKCON Bangalore. The court observed contempt of court proceedings are meant to protect the dignity of the court but the petitioners in this case have put this application as they have an axe to grind against the respondents. The divisional bench of Supreme Court was hearing a petition filed by ISKCON Mumbai here in the capital.
Brief on Petitions
ISKCON Bangalore and ISKCON Mumbai are having doctrinal differences on succession to seat of the acharya of ISKCON, which was founded by His Divine Grace AC Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.
ISKCON Bangalore going by the strict written directives of its founder Acharya Srila Prabhupada subscribes to the doctrine that His Divine Grace did not appoint any successor acharya after his physical departure. On the other hand Srila Prabhupada established a rtvik system of initiation wherein he continues to remain the only diksa guru of ISKCON. Whereas ISKCON Mumbai, says that the governing body has the right to appoint successor to Srila Prabhupada.
Due to these doctrinal differences ISKCON Bangalore had approached courts to give a permanent injunction against ISKCON Mumbai to not interfere in its administration in anyway. The City Civil court gave permanent injunction to the effect that ISKCON Mumbai should not interfere with the affairs of ISKCON Bangalore. This verdict was passed on April 17th 2009 after the honorable court conducted a day to day trial for over three months with over seven hundred documents filed by both sides.
ISKCON Mumbai had appealed against this permanent injunction in the Honorable High Courts of Karnataka. The appeal came before a divisional bench headed by Hon Justice KL Manjunath. During the course of the hearings Sri Jaichaitanya dasa the secretary ISKCON applied to the divisional bench that Hon. Justice Manjunath should recuse from the case.
On receiving the application Hon. Justice Manjunath recused from the case but sought to initiate contempt proceedings against Secretary of ISKCON Bangalore and several other advocates. The case is still under progress in the High court.
ISKCON Mumbai filed a petition in the High Court, on its own seeking to initiate contempt of court proceedings against entire ISKCON Bangalore society’s Governing Council. Its plea was that the entire Governing Council was responsible for the action of Secretary and that their silence is also an indication of their complicity in the contempt.
The divisional bench headed by Hon Justice Sreedhar Rao, dismissed the application of ISKCON Mumbai giving its verdict that Governing Council of ISKCON Bangalore cannot be made party to the contempt. On this ISKCON Mumbai appealed to Supreme Court seeking special leave petitions to initiate contempt, which was dismissed by the apex court.
Yours in service of God and Humanity,
Madhu Pandit Dasa,
President ISKCON Bangalore.
Encl: Copy of the order of the Supreme Court.
PADA: […] This is why they sued our Akshaya Patra food devotees and took this all the way to the Delhi high courts at a cost to them of millions, they know that our free food program is getting many good comments from highly placed government officials and so on, and thus the ritviks are gaining credibility at the highest levels, so they have to cut us off now, or lose.
Apparently Krishna sided with us, they lost their case and now they have to pay Delhi High court costs, fees, and our lawyers costs as well, in addition to all their expenses of flying people around to attend, meetings with lawyers, and so on, all costing a great deal. So this is a sign of how desperate they are. Certainly they must be gradually recognizing that they cannot keep up this acharya charade forever, the gates are closing.
So dialogue is a good idea, perhaps at some point they may want to take down their walls and actually try to sit down and discuss these things with us. In the meantime, we will continue onwards because we cannot wait forever for them to change. We have to prepare for the fact that they may never change. So at least we can say, we attempted dialogue.
This also happened at Kurukshetra, Krishna wanted to dialogue, so He tried to avoid a conflict. To say that acharyas are fallen down is like scraping fingernails on a blackboard to me, I will not be able to accept this, so unfortunately this has been the whole cause of conflict all these years, they say acharyas become debauchees and we say, no way! Hopefully they will more and more ritvik-ize their program, as its now happening, albeit slowly. Then we can unite and preach under one banner.
Very good, Iskcon Mumbai is wasting all Krishna’s laxmi for nothing on their personal feud. They are making aparadh # 1 by trying to block and trouble and destroy the devotoional service of other Vaisnavas. May Lord Krishna give you completer victory to finish off the nusiance efforts of fools and rascals. and trample them in the dust.